Property value ramping up is always both exciting and somewhat worrying. Nobody wants to buy at the peak! It's easy to think that anything that goes up has to go down one day, but it doesn't really apply to Real estate. Cycles exist and you don't want to get caught in it with the short end of the stick. Though the strategy of "just wait for it to crash" has mostly been proven to get people to never jump in, and miss out on appreciation. Colorado Hard Money Lender gave us their perspective on what's going on today in Aspen, with all the implication it has for our entire valley.
The data is staggering in three months from June through August, the median home price in Aspen for a single family home doubled, with the average sales price north of 7 million. Has Aspen hit a peak? How do the other Colorado ski towns compare? Are we at risk of a bubble? What resort town is most at risk of a fall?
What was in the Colorado ski town sales data?
First, I looked at median sales price in four major Colorado Resort Towns (Aspen/Snowmass, Vail/Beavercreek, Breckenridge/Frisco/Keystone/Copper Mountain, and Steamboat. The reason I am focusing on the median is because the average can be greatly skewed in the mountains by large sales prices. For example, a 40 million dollar sale in Aspen greatly increases the average. All of the mountain communities have shown substantial increases in median home prices with Aspen doubling and Vail/Beavercreek up almost 53% during the three months.
Note: (the data comes from the Colorado Association of Realtors) When you look at Routt county the data might seem off… you are correct, the median home price in Steamboat is now around 1.1m as there are lower sales in more rural parts of the county. I broke out the sales by county where each resort is located to keep everything consistent so I didn’t have to compare mountain sales versus town sales, versus etc…
When I annualize the sales over the year, the increases are not as crazy as the three-month summer season.
Days on the market plummets
In all of the ski resort markets throughout Colorado, inventory has plummeted. This is not surprising as there is little available land and build costs are extremely high. Low inventories will continue to propel prices higher throughout the resort communities.
Has Aspen peaked?
Based on the huge run up in prices over the last three months where the median sales price has doubled, I think Aspen is about at a peak. With an average sales price over $7 million the available pool of buyers is dwindling which will dampen demand. There still might be a little bit of gas left in the tank but Aspen is somewhere near a peak.
Where do we go from here in the Colorado ski towns?
Vail, Breckenridge and Steamboat could have a bit more upside left in this cycle, with days of inventory precipitously low, prices are bound to continue to increase. There is nothing in the pipeline that will substantially alter the inventory situation. Furthermore, as Aspen has gotten so expensive with the average sales price around 7m, Vail, Breckenridge, and Steamboat look like relative bargains which will continue to attract buyers that are priced out of Aspen but still want the Colorado resort lifestyle
Will there be a bubble in the Colorado ski resort real estate?
This is the most common question and many are convinced that the mountain towns will endure a precipitous fall. Unfortunately, this couldn’t be farther from the truth. There is no bubble in the various resort communities in Colorado for three reasons.
There is little if any excess inventory for the market to absorb, furthermore there will not be large defaults due to the equity in properties and jumbo requirements with substantial down payments.
Demand will stay constant or increase. It is not like all of the sudden Aspen is not going to be a desirable place to live or visit.
The most important variable is the amount of cash transactions. Look at the percentage of properties bought with cash in each of the resort communities (source land title). For example in Steamboat almost half of all transactions have no financing and in Aspen this number is 62%. The amount of cash transactions greatly mitigate the downside risks as there is unlikely to be a distress situation that forces a fire sale of a property like a foreclosure would.
What town is more at risk for a correction?
I use the term “more at risk” in a relative sense as I am very doubtful there will be a large correction. Summit county has the smallest percentage of cash transactions which makes it more susceptible to a correction. Since the pandemic struck Summit county has become a hotbed for remote workers and many workers from the Denver front range that only need to access Denver a few days a week. Breckenridge has become an “ex-urb” of the Denver metro area which is why a higher percentage of transactions involve financing as opposed to destinations like Steamboat or Aspen.
Although Summit county is “more at risk” than Steamboat or Aspen, the risk if very minimal as Summit county has one of the lowest inventories of all the mountain towns.
When the pandemic struck, I was concerned about real estate values. My prediction was that they would hold steady. I would have never predicted that Aspen would double in a 3 month period, but looking back onto what has transpired since March it is not surprising.
Buyers want to be in safe places and high net worth executives have realized they can work most of the time or even all the time in a great location with many of the same amenities they had in their respective cities without much if any negatives that city life brings. This trend will obviously slow as vaccines are approved, but I don’t think that we will see a bursting of the bubble due to the large amount of cash transactions, low inventory, and desirability to live and play in the various resort towns.